Laryngeal and vocal alterations after thyroidectomy / Alterações laríngeas e vocais após tireoidectomia

Abstract Introduction: Dysphonia is a common symptom after thyroidectomy. Objective: To analyze the vocal symptoms, auditory-perceptual and acoustic vocal, videolaryngoscopy, the surgical procedures and histopathological findings in patients undergoing thyroidectomy. Methods: Prospective study. Patients submitted to thyroidectomy were evaluated as follows: anamnesis, laryngoscopy, and acoustic vocal assessments. Moments: pre-operative, 1st post (15 days), 2nd post (1 month), 3rd post (3 months), and 4th post (6 months). Results: Among the 151 patients (130 women; 21 men). Type of surgery: lobectomy + isthmectomy n = 40, total thyroidectomy n = 88, thyroidectomy + lymph node dissection n = 23. Vocal symptoms were reported by 42 patients in the 1st post (27.8%) decreasing to 7.2% after 6 months. In the acoustic analysis, f0 and APQ were decreased in women. Videolaryngoscopies showed that 144 patients (95.3%) had normal exams in the preoperative moment. Vocal fold palsies were diagnosed in 34 paralyzes at the 1st post, 32 recurrent laryngeal nerve (lobectomy + isthmectomy n = 6; total thyroidectomy n = 17; thyroidectomy + lymph node dissection n = 9) and 2 superior laryngeal nerve (lobectomy + isthmectomy n = 1; Total thyroidectomy + lymph node dissection n = 1). After 6 months, 10 patients persisted with paralysis of the recurrent laryngeal nerve (6.6%). Histopathology and correlation with vocal fold palsy: colloid nodular goiter (n = 76; palsy n = 13), thyroiditis (n = 8; palsy n = 0), and carcinoma (n = 67; palsy n = 21). Conclusion: Vocal symptoms, reported by 27.8% of the patients on the 1st post decreased to 7% in 6 months. In the acoustic analysis, f0 and APQ were decreased. Transient paralysis of the vocal folds secondary to recurrent and superior laryngeal nerve injury occurred in, respectively, 21% and 1.3% of the patients, decreasing to 6.6% and 0% after 6 months.

Resumo Introdução: A disfonia é um sintoma comum após a tireoidectomia. Objetivo: Analisar os sintomas vocais, auditivo-perceptivos e acústica vocal, videolaringoscopia, procedimento cirúrgico e achados histopatológicos em pacientes submetidos à tireoidectomia. Método: Estudo prospectivo. Pacientes submetidos à tireoidectomia foram avaliados da seguinte forma: anamnese, laringoscopia e avaliações vocais acústicas. Momentos: pré-operatório, 1ª avaliação pós (15 dias), 2ª avaliação pós (1 mês), 3ª avaliação pós (3 meses) e 4ª avaliação pós-operatória (6 meses). Resultados: Dos 151 pacientes, 130 eram mulheres e 21, homens. Tipos de cirurgia: lobectomia + istmectomia n = 40, tireoidectomia total n = 88, tireoidectomia + dissecção de linfonodo n = 23. Sintomas vocais foram relatados por 42 pacientes na 1ª avaliação pós-operatória (27,8%), reduzidos para 7,2% após 6 meses. Na análise acústica, f0 e APQ estavam diminuídos nas mulheres. As videolaringoscopias mostraram que 144 pacientes (95,3%) tiveram exames normais no momento pré-operatório. Paralisia das cordas vocais foi diagnosticada em 34 pacientes na 1ª avaliação pós-operatória, 32 do nervo laríngeo recorrente (lobectomia + istmectomia - n = 6; tireoidectomia total - n = 17; tireoidectomia total + dissecção de linfonodos - n = 9) e 2 do nervo laríngeo superior (lobectomia + istmectomia - n = 1; tireoidectomia total + dissecção de linfonodos - n = 1). Após 6 meses, 10 pacientes persistiram com paralisia do nervo laríngeo recorrente (6,6%). Histopatologia e correlação com paralisia das cordas vocais: bócio coloide nodular (n = 76; paralisia n = 13), tireoidite (n = 8; paralisia n = 0) e carcinoma (n = 67; paralisia n = 21). Conclusão: Os sintomas vocais, relatados por 27,8% dos pacientes na 1ª avaliação pós-operatória, diminuíram para 7% em 6 meses. Na análise acústica, f0 e APQ diminuíram. A paralisia transitória de cordas vocais secundária à lesão do nervo laríngeo recorrente e nervo laríngeo superior ocorreu, respectivamente, em 21% e 1,3% dos pacientes, reduziu-se para 6,6% e 0% após 6 meses.

Recurrent laryngeal nerve injury in thyroid surgery

Vocal cord paresis or paralysis due to iatrogenic injury of the recurrent laryngeal nerve [RLNI] is one of the main problems in thyroid surgery. Although many procedures have been introduced to prevent the nerve injury, still the incidence of recurrent laryngeal nerve palsy varies between 1.5-14%. The aim of the present study is to assess the risk factors of recurrent laryngeal nerve injury during thyroid surgery. Patients who had thyroid surgery between 1990 and 2005 and were admitted to the surgical department of King Fahd hospital of the University, Al-Khobar, Saudi Arabia were enrolled for this retrospective review, Factors predisposing to recurrent laryngeal nerve injury were evaluated such as pathology of the lesions and the type of operations and identification of recurrent laryngeal nerve intra-operatively. Preoperative and postoperative indirect laryngoscopic examinations were performed for all patients. 340 patients were included in this study. Transient unilateral vocal cord problems occurred in 11 [3.2%] cases, and in 1 [0.3%] case, it became permanent [post Rt. Hemithyroidectomy]. Bilateral vocal cord problems occurred in 2 cases [0.58%], but none became permanent. There were significant increases in the incidence of recurrent laryngeal nerve injury in secondary operation [21.7% in secondary vs. 2.8% in primary, p=0.001], total/near total thyroidectomy [7.2% in total vs. 1.9% in subtotal, p=0.024], non-identification of RLN during surgery [7.6% in non-identification vs. 2.6% in identification, p=0.039] and in malignant disease [12.8% in malignant vs. 2.9% in benign, p=0.004]. However, there was no significant difference in the incidence of recurrent laryngeal nerve injury with regards to gender [4.1% in male vs 3.8% in female, p=0.849]. The present study showed that thyroid carcinoma, re-operation for recurrent goiter, non-identification of RLN and total thyroidectomy were associated with a significantly increased risk of operative recurrent laryngeal nerve injury

Experiencia clínica en el manejo de parálisis cordales en posición abierta: tratamiento actual / Clinical experience in the management of vocal cords paralysis in abduction position: actual treatment

Introduction: The larynx is nerved by the recurrent and superior laryngeal nerves, translating its damage in pareses or paralysis of vocal cords, causing hoarseness in most of patients, and occasionally dispnea and deglutory alterations. The management of vocal cords paralysis in abduction position has been controversial. It seems that phoniatric treatment would seem to be a reasonable and effective alternative because the compensation capacity. Surgical manage, in other hand, has offered demonstrated effectiveness in the paralyses that don’t respond to phoniatric treatment, emphasizing techniques of medialization thiroplasty. Objectives: To reflect our epidemiology, phoniatric manage and experience as surgical team in medialization hiroplasty and to evaluate the results. Materials and Methods: retrospective study of patients with vocal cord paralysis in abduction position evaluated in Voice Unit of Clinic Hospital of University of Chile. Complete otolaryngological evaluation plus laryngeal electromyography were performed. Two groups were analyzed according manage received, describing clinicallythe degree of hoarseness at the beginning and the end of treatment. Results: 61 percent of the nonsurgical manage paralysis causes were secondary to surgery, mainly on the thyroid gland (81 percent). In these a significant improvement of the hoarseness with the phoniatric manage exists. In the group subject medialization thiroplasty 55 percent were secondary to surgery with a 77 percent of postoperating satisfactory evaluation.

Vocal fold immobility after thyroidectomy with intraoperative recurrent laryngeal nerve monitoring

CONTEXT AND OBJECTIVE: Intraoperative nerve monitoring has emerged as a valuable tool to facilitate recurrent laryngeal nerve identification during thyroid surgery, thereby avoiding its injury. The aim was to evaluate vocal fold mobility in patients who underwent thyroidectomy with intraoperative nerve monitoring. DESIGN AND SETTING: Cohort formed by a consecutive series of patients, at a tertiary cancer hospital. METHODS: The subjects were patients who underwent thyroidectomy using intraoperative laryngeal nerve monitoring, between November 2003 and January 2006. Descriptive analysis of the results and comparison with a similar group of patients who did not undergo nerve monitoring were performed. RESULTS: A total of 104 patients were studied. Total thyroidectomy was performed on 65 patients. Vocal fold immobility (total or partial) was detected in 12 patients (6.8 percent of the nerves at risk) at the first postoperative evaluation. Only six (3.4 percent of the nerves at risk) continued to present vocal fold immobility three months after surgery. Our previous series with 100 similar patients without intraoperative nerve monitoring revealed that 12 patients (7.5 percent) presented vocal fold immobility at the early examination, and just 5 (3.1 percent) maintained this immobility three months after surgery, without significant difference between the two series. CONCLUSION: In this series, the use of intraoperative nerve monitoring did not decrease the rate of vocal fold immobility.

CONTEXTO E OBJETIVO: A monitorização intra-operatória de nervos surgiu como uma ferramenta valiosa para facilitar a identificação do nervo laríngeo recorrente durante a cirurgia de tireóide, evitando a sua lesão. O objetivo foi avaliar a mobilidade das pregas vocais em pacientes submetidos a tireoidectomia com monitorização intra-operatória do nervo laríngeo recorrente. TIPO E LOCAL DO ESTUDO: Coorte de uma série consecutiva de pacientes em um hospital terciário de tratamento de câncer. MÉTODOS: Pacientes foram submetidos à cirurgia de tireóide usando a monitorização intra-operatória do nervo laríngeo recorrente, entre novembro de 2003 e janeiro de 2006. Uma análise descritiva dos resultados e uma comparação com um grupo similar de pacientes que não foram submetidos a monitorização dos nervos foram realizadas. RESULTADOS: Um total de 104 pacientes foi estudado. Tireoidectomia total realizada em 65 pacientes. Imobilidade de pregas vocais (parcial ou total) foi detectada em 12 pacientes (6.8 por cento dos nervos sob risco) na primeira avaliação pós-operatória. Apenas 6 (3.4 por cento dos nervos sob risco) permaneceram com imobilidade de prega vocal três meses após a cirurgia. Nossa série prévia com 100 pacientes similares sem a monitorização intra-operatória revelou que 12 pacientes (7.5 por cento) apresentaram imobilidade de prega vocal na avaliação precoce, e apenas 5 (3.1 por cento) mantiveram a imobilidade três meses após a cirurgia, sem diferença significativa entre as séries. CONCLUSÃO: Nesta série, o uso da monitorização intra-operatória do nervo laríngeo recorrente não diminuiu a taxa de imobilidade de prega vocal.

Etiology of bilateral recurrent laryngeal nerve paralysis in Sudanese patients

To highlight the occurrence of bilateral recurrent laryngeal nerve paralysis, a grave condition which is frequently overlooked, to reflect the author's personal experience with this condition over an 18-year period in Sudanese patients, and to identify the etiological factors involved in this condition. Patients and Hospital records of all cases [n=28] that presented to the ENT Department of Wad Medani Teaching Hospital in Central State of Sudan over a period of 18 years [1983 - 2001] with bilateral recurrent laryngeal nerve paralysis were reviewed. The total number of patients was 28. Twenty-five cases [25] were females while 3 were males. The female to male ratio was 8.3:10. Patients' ages ranged from 27-75 years with a mean age of 43.2 years. The symptom common to all patients was stridor on exertion. The main etiological factor was thyroidectomy [78.6%] followed in the order of frequency by malignant tumor invasion of the nerves [14.2%], neurological causes [3.6%], and trauma [3.6%]. The most common etiological factor of bilateral recurrent laryngeal nerve paralysis was found to be thyroid surgery [78.6%], followed by malignant tumor invasion of the nerves [14.2%], neurological causes [3.6%] and trauma [3.6%]. Patients undergoing thyroid surgery should have voice and vocal cord mobility assessed by a lamyngologist before and after surgery